← all Middle 8 videos
19:31 · 3,555 words of transcript · watch on YouTube
- The numbers behind the premise: R&B and hip hop still hold the largest US market share at 25.9 percent in Luminate's 2023 mid-year report, down from 26.8 and 27.7 in the two years before, and that slide is happening during record streaming volumes.
▶ 00:00:39
- Three causes are named for the fatigue: the biggest artists moving into phases where hits are not the goal, the deaths of Pop Smoke, Juice WRLD and XXXTentacion leaving a hole in the middle of the genre, and a shortage of new acts ready to take the top.
▶ 00:01:21
- The structural complaint is that commercialisation diluted the rebellious edge, leaving tracks engineered for success with catchy hooks, polished production and guest features in place of rawness and social commentary.
▶ 00:04:07
- M.I.A.'s Maya is treated as the prototype moment, a divisive 2010 record that laid out the five elements the experimental wave would run on.
▶ 00:05:03
- The first of those is cheap portable gear. Maya was self-produced at home in LA, on top of the Mayan pyramids in Mexico and on holiday in Hawaii, which is the same shift that lets clipping build a track around an alarm clock and JPEGMAFIA around a clicking pen.
▶ 00:05:24
- The bedroom-studio point gets a concrete illustration: clipping recorded in a storage room at a grandfather's dentist office, which turned into the lobby and then into their own space.
▶ 00:06:24
- Internet culture is the second element. Maya's title was styled in leetspeak partly to dodge search engines, and the album made M.I.A. the most blogged-about artist for weeks, a year before Spotify reached the United States.
▶ 00:08:34
- Distribution followed. Death Grips self-released No Love Deep Web online for free without label approval, and BROCKHAMPTON formed on a forum and used streaming to put out three albums in a year with no label.
▶ 00:09:34
- JPEGMAFIA is offered as the clearest punk case, a Brooklyn upbringing on Ice Cube and Chuck D alongside Bad Brains and Fear, writing, producing and mixing his own records because handing them to other people wrecked them.
▶ 00:12:54
- The conclusion reframes the data: a falling market share is a shift rather than a downturn, with the commercial fatigue opening room for the artistic turn the video has spent twenty minutes documenting.
▶ 00:19:05